Connect with us

BUSINESS

India Reopens Bank Reform With a Six-Month Patel Panel

A Suresh Patel-led six-month panel will rewrite Indian bank rules, reopening unfinished Narasimham and Nayak fights on credit, ownership and vigilance.

Published

on

New Delhi on October 30 named a six-month High Level Committee on Banking for Viksit Bharat, chaired by former Central Vigilance Commissioner Suresh N. Patel. The finance ministry asked it to propose structural and legal changes so Indian banks are globally competitive, financially inclusive and resilient by 2047.

The brief returns to fights that two earlier reform generations never closed: who owns public banks, who they must lend to, and how far vigilance rules reach into the boardroom.

Delhi Names a Six-Month Banking Reform Panel

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman had already proposed a committee on banking for Viksit Bharat in the February 1 Budget, almost nine months before the names were published. The Budget described a sector with strong balance sheets, historic highs in profitability, better asset quality, and banking coverage exceeding 98 percent of villages. It asked the new panel to review the financial sector and line it up with the next phase of growth, while guarding stability, inclusion and consumer protection.

The October 30 note from the ministry is more specific. Patel chairs the panel. The members are Shirish Chandra Murmu, a sitting deputy governor of the Reserve Bank of India; Padmaja Chunduru, former managing director and chief executive of Indian Bank; and N. S. Vishwanathan, a former RBI deputy governor. The joint secretary for banking in the Department of Financial Services is member secretary. Tenure is six months.

There is no private-sector bank chief on the list, and no working head of a regional rural bank or urban cooperative. The people who live with the rural and cooperative statutes are in the terms of reference, not in the room. A sitting RBI deputy governor will help write advice on the legal framework his own institution administers.

THE SEVEN TASKS ON THE PAPER

  1. Bank rules: Judge current prudential norms against global practice and sketch a path to globally competitive banks.
  2. The legal net: Review regulation and law for commercial banks, Regional Rural Banks and cooperative banks, and ease the doing of banking.
  3. Long-term capital: Size funding needs for banks, development finance institutions and NBFCs, and name sources that can support credit growth.
  4. Cost of funds: Examine why businesses pay different costs of capital, and offer options that lift private investment.
  5. Machines and people: Map AI and digital change, with cyber safeguards, plus a plan to hire and train a future-ready workforce.
  6. Directed credit: Review the Priority Sector Lending framework and the Lead Bank Scheme for relevance, effect and coordination.
  7. Open clause: Take up any other matter the government refers to the committee.

The ministry’s own language asks for structural, institutional, regulatory and legislative reforms. That is a licence to touch statutes, not only circulars. It is also a six-month licence. The last time Delhi ordered a full architecture review of this width, the work ran in years, not seasons.

What Narasimham and Nayak Left Unfinished

M. Narasimham’s first committee, in 1991, told a newly liberalising state to let banks price credit, hold more capital, and stop treating every loan as a social assignment. The second Narasimham panel, in 1998, came back for bad loans, board autonomy, and a smaller government share. Private banks were licensed. Asset reconstruction and recovery law followed. Majority government ownership did not go away.

The RBI then asked P.J. Nayak, former chairman and chief executive of Axis Bank, to look at boards. His committee was formed on January 20, 2014, and the report is dated May 13, 2014. It said public-sector bank boards were disempowered, director selection was compromised, and dual control by the finance ministry and the RBI made strategy slow. It wanted the Bank Nationalisation Acts of 1970 and 1980, and the SBI statutes, repealed, with all banks put under company law and government shares parked in a Bank Investment Company.

FOUR BANKING REFORM PANELS

Panel Year Chair Core brief
Narasimham I 1991 M. Narasimham Rebuild the financial system after liberalisation
Narasimham II 1998 M. Narasimham Stronger banks, fewer bad loans, more board autonomy
Nayak 2014 P.J. Nayak Professional boards and distance from government control
Viksit Bharat panel 2026 Suresh N. Patel Full-sector review, including PSL and cooperatives

Those earlier briefs still describe the live arguments. Directed credit is back as a formal review. Rural and cooperative law is back. So is the hunt for scale that can fund infrastructure and factories. The new paper adds AI, cyber risk, talent, NBFCs and the cost of capital, which Narasimham never had to treat as a 2047 industrial problem. The old fights did not move off the desk to make room for the new ones.

The Chair Ran a Bank and the CVC

Patel is not an outsider dropped onto a banking file. Management Development Institute Gurgaon records four decades in the system: Allahabad Bank, then Dena Bank, where he rose to general manager, convened the State Level Bankers’ Committee in Gujarat, and sat on the board of Dena Gujarat Gramin Bank. He was executive director at Oriental Bank of Commerce and MD and CEO of Andhra Bank. He holds a B.Sc. in agriculture, an LL.B., and a CAIIB certificate. After leaving line banking he was Vigilance Commissioner in 2020-2021 and Central Vigilance Commissioner in 2021-2022, later chair of the Advisory Board for Banking and Financial Frauds, and an independent director at NaBFID, the infrastructure development finance institution.

That mix is the tell. Delhi put a career public-sector banker who also ran the vigilance commission on a brief that includes “globally competitive” banks. Nayak had listed external vigilance by the CVC and the CBI, alongside dual regulation and pay caps, as constraints that stop public banks competing with private ones. His cure was ownership, not another oversight layer.

If the Government stake in these banks were to reduce to less than 50 per cent, together with certain other executive measures taken, all these external constraints would disappear.

P.J. Nayak, Committee to Review Governance of Boards of Banks in India, RBI, May 2014

The same review of governance of bank boards called government control, without professional boards, a fiscal risk. It wanted a Bank Boards Bureau as a bridge, then a Bank Investment Company, then real power on the boards themselves. The nationalisation acts were not repealed. Public banks are still majority-owned. CVC jurisdiction over them did not vanish. Naming a former CVC to write the next roadmap does not settle that argument. It puts the argument in the chair.

Patel also sits on NaBFID’s board while the panel is asked to study long-term capital for development finance institutions. That is not a hidden job. It is a reminder that the people drafting the 2047 credit machine already live inside pieces of it.

Priority Sector Lending Comes Back on the Table

Task six is the one that will start a fight outside North Block. Banks have been told for almost five decades to send at least 40 percent of credit to the priority sector. The floor became a widening list: farm loans, small firms, weaker sections, housing, education, renewables, and, after January 2026, certain loans to the National Cooperative Development Corporation. Each addition pleased a constituency. Each one also gave banks more ways to hit a target without reaching a small farmer in a thin district.

In May, the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister published an economic impact analysis of Priority Sector Lending (working paper WP/48/2026). The paper said priority advances have been correlated with less rural poverty and with more investment by firms and farms. It also said dumping credit into weak uses can hurt productivity, and that directed lending can weigh on bank profits through defaults and high handling costs. Using night-time lights as a stand-in for local output, it did not find that faster priority-loan growth lifts a district’s output over two years.

The authors want the aim shifted from economic categories to social equity. Keep the original targets for small and marginal farmers, small industry and weaker sections, they wrote, and drop legacy items that no longer belong, including a separate agriculture target that also captures loans to corporate farms. That is a narrower PSL, not a louder one. Farm lobbies and some state governments will hear it as a retreat. Large banks that already buy Priority Sector Lending Certificates to fill gaps will hear it as relief.

The Lead Bank Scheme is on the same line of the brief. The RBI issued a revised scheme in June 2026, tightening district credit plans, Lead District Managers, and rural credit-deposit ratios. The Patel panel is now asked to judge the scheme’s relevance anyway. Two reviews of the same coordination machine, months apart, means Delhi is not sure the June rewrite settled the politics of who gets credit in a block.

THE CREDIT RULES THE PANEL INHERITS

  • The floor: Scheduled commercial banks have been held to a 40 percent priority-sector share for almost five decades.
  • The Budget claim: Village banking coverage was put at more than 98 percent when the committee was first promised on February 1.
  • The rural book: Regional Rural Banks’ gross loans rose 10.3 percent to ₹5.78 lakh crore in FY2025-26, from ₹5.24 lakh crore, according to finance ministry data.
  • The rural hit rate: RRBs’ average PSL achievement was 91.7 percent against a 75 percent target of adjusted net bank credit in that year, the same data show.

RRBs already overshoot a target that is much higher than the 40 percent commercial-bank floor. If the panel narrows PSL toward small farmers and weaker sections, rural banks look like the delivery channel. If it treats PSL as a drag on globally competitive balance sheets, those same banks become the problem child. Both readings fit the same term of reference.

Rural Banks, Cooperatives and a Capital Gap

Task two puts Regional Rural Banks and cooperative banks in the same legal review as the large commercial system. That is overdue on paper and messy in practice. Cooperatives still answer to state registrars as well as to the RBI. Urban cooperative banks have spent the past two years getting more room on branches, housing loans, gold-loan ceilings and a PSL target cut toward 60 percent. Rural cooperatives have been pulled into credit-guarantee schemes and given higher dairy and housing limits. A “ease of doing banking” rewrite can either lock in that thaw or pull cooperatives toward commercial-bank law they were not built to carry.

Capital is the quieter bomb. Task three asks for a long-term funding plan for banks, development finance institutions and NBFCs together. Public banks still come to the owner when Basel buffers need topping up. NBFCs fund themselves in markets that close when wholesale money gets jumpy. DFIs are supposed to take the long infrastructure end that commercial banks cannot hold on short deposits. Putting all three on one page is an admission that bank credit alone will not build the 2047 capex cycle.

Task four, on the cost of capital for business, is the industrial-policy clause. It is not a banking hygiene item. It asks why two firms in the same trade can face different funding costs, and what policy would crowd in private investment. That can mean cheaper long bonds, a thicker corporate-bond market, or more pressure on banks to lend to factories. Shaktikanta Das, Principal Secretary 2 to the Prime Minister and a former RBI governor, had already pointed at that gap when he spoke in Mumbai on October 27, three days before the panel was named. He cited industrial credit growth of nearly 20 percent in July as an early sign that private investment may be stirring, and he told lenders to move from plain company loans toward long-term capital for infrastructure, semiconductors, electronics and defence.

Task five, on AI, cyber risk and hiring, is the one part of the brief that does not have a 1990s ancestor. Banks already run large analytics shops and still lose people to fintech pay. A six-month talent strategy will not reset pay scales in public banks that still live under government compensation rules. Nayak flagged that pay gap in 2014. It is still there. A cyber roadmap is easier to write than to fund, and easier to fund than to staff.

The Mandate Skips the Merger Question

The published terms never ask for another merger list, a cut in the government’s 51 percent floor, or a change in voting rights. They ask for a “roadmap for creating globally competitive banks.” In Indian banking English, that phrase has usually meant fewer, larger public banks. Das used the same idea, in public, while the committee was still unnamed.

The consolidation of PSBs over the past decade has laid an important foundation. The next frontier is the creation of institutions with the scale, resilience, and international presence to compete alongside the world’s leading banking entities. Larger financial institutions are better positioned to underwrite complex projects and absorb shocks in an increasingly volatile environment.

Shaktikanta Das, Principal Secretary 2 to the Prime Minister, Mumbai, October 27, 2026

He also split the work: smaller lenders should stay close to households and small firms in smaller cities, he said, while the large institutions take infrastructure and manufacturing. That is a two-tier system in all but the notification. The Patel panel can adopt it without ever printing the word merger. It can also ignore it. The open seventh term lets the government feed in extra questions later, which is how consolidation, FDI caps and voting rights would enter if Delhi wants them on the record after the politics are tested.

The first public reading of the announcement, in the replies that followed the ministry note, was that a competitiveness panel is a vehicle to sell public sector banks. The terms do not say that. Branch staff hear a different threat, which is another round of process change on already stretched ledgers. Both readings are older than this committee. Narasimham wanted fewer weak banks and more autonomy. Nayak wanted the owner to step back so the remaining banks could compete. Neither got the ownership decision they asked for. What they got, in 2017 and 2020, was consolidation under the same owner.

Patel now has six months to write on PSL, cooperatives, capital, the cost of funds, AI and whatever else the government adds. The nationalisation acts, the 40 percent credit rule, and CVC reach over public banks are all still in force. The six-month clock started on October 30.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of CUMBERNAULD MEDIA, which he runs as an independent publication after a decade in journalism spent moving from reporting to editing. His habit is to open the document before the summary of it. A company result is read from the filing rather than the press release, a court or regulatory decision from the judgment itself, a scientific finding from the paper and its methods section rather than the headline claim, and a sporting sanction from the governing body's own ruling. That approach shapes coverage across news, business and technology as much as science, sports and entertainment, and it carries into the lifestyle, travel, auto and gaming pages, where product specifications are checked against the manufacturer's sheet and, where possible, against Harry's own testing. Every number is checked before publication, and where a source's figures are disputed the story says so. Corrections follow a public policy and are marked on the page. Readers anywhere in the world who write in get a reply from him, and the address is support@cumbernauld-media.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending