ENTERTAINMENT
McAllan Fights to Keep a BBC Scotland Channel Few Watch
Màiri McAllan asks Ofcom to stop BBC Scotland leaving live TV, even as the channel reaches 12% weekly and its shows already run on BBC One, Two and iPlayer.
Culture Secretary Màiri McAllan has asked Ofcom to review BBC plans to take the BBC Scotland channel off live television in Spring 2027.
She told the regulator the plan is “wholly unacceptable”. The BBC will keep the brand on iPlayer and move shows onto BBC One and BBC Two, while the linear channel now draws 12% of Scotland in an average week.
McAllan Asks Ofcom to Halt the Switch-Off
On 28 October McAllan wrote to Ofcom chief executive Melanie Dawes and director for Scotland Glenn Preston, eight days after the BBC set out plans to close the linear BBC Scotland channel with BBC Three and Radio 4 Extra. Broadcasting is a Westminster matter, so Holyrood cannot veto the switch. She asked the regulator to test it against the BBC’s operating licence anyway.
The letter treats the 2019 channel as the thing that made Scotland visible on a remote control. Closing the live service, she wrote, would “reverse progress in improving the visibility and representation of Scotland within the UK’s broadcasting landscape”. She also warned that viewers who still use ordinary television would be hit first.
The people of Scotland must be able to turn on their televisions and radios and find something of their lives reflected back to them. With underinvestment of the licence fee revenues in Scotland, disparity between Gaelic and Welsh-language broadcasting, a total absence of Commonwealth Games coverage on BBC One Scotland (as just one example of Scottish cultural and sporting life) and now the closure of the BBC Scotland channel, this aim is not just under threat but all but extinguished.
Màiri McAllan, Culture Secretary, letter to Ofcom
Director-General Matt Brittin told staff the BBC must save £500 million by 2028. “Much of the great content they currently carry will still be found where audiences already enjoy it on iPlayer and Sounds,” he said. BBC Scotland confirmed the change on its own account the same day.
The BBC has announced plans to close its Scotland linear TV station as it seeks to make £500m savings.
The channel, which started in February 2019, will move to BBC iPlayer in spring next year, although its nightly News at Seven programme will close.https://t.co/NgU5Yumg4i
— BBC Scotland (@BBCScotland) October 20, 2026
The Channel Scots Rarely Chose
The corporation’s own Scotland pack for 2025/26 is blunt about the live channel. It reached 12% of Scotland’s population each week, down from 13% the year before, on BARB’s as-viewed measure of 15 minutes or more among viewers aged four and over.
Scottish BBC television as a whole still finds a much bigger audience. 42% of adults aged 16 and over watched BBC Scotland TV content in an average week, the same share as in 2024/25, counted on a lighter three-minute reach. Across TV, radio and online, 54% of adults used BBC Scotland content, down from 56%. Pan-BBC reach in Scotland was 80%.
HOW SCOTS USE THE BBC
| Service | Weekly reach 2025/26 | Weekly reach 2024/25 |
|---|---|---|
| BBC Scotland linear channel (4+, 15 mins) | 12% | 13% |
| BBC Scotland TV content (adults 16+, 3 mins) | 42% | 42% |
| BBC Scotland content, TV, radio and online | 54% | 56% |
| Any BBC TV, iPlayer, radio or online | 80% | 83% |
Those rows are why the political fight and the viewing fight have split. The EPG button is weak. Scottish programmes, once they sit on BBC One, BBC Two or iPlayer, are not. Signed-in accounts watching BBC Scotland titles on iPlayer have grown 70% in four years, and more than 1 million accounts now do that in an average week. Scotland as a whole had 1.2 million weekly iPlayer accounts in both of the past two years.
Ofcom’s Media Nations 2026 Scotland report puts linear television’s weekly reach in Scotland at 55% in 2025, down six points in a year. Broadcaster television as a whole reached 68%. Live TV is shrinking, and it has not shrunk to nothing, which is the part of McAllan’s letter the audience data still supports.
Why the 2019 Launch Never Found a Crowd
The BBC built the channel as a political answer as much as a schedule. In February 2017 then director-general Tony Hall promised a dedicated Scottish service, with “a brand-new Scotland-edited international news programme at its heart”. Ofcom approved it in June 2018 on a £32 million budget and about 140 jobs. BBC Two Scotland closed so the new channel could take the slot.
FROM PROMISE TO SWITCH-OFF
- February 2017: Hall announces a dedicated Scotland television channel and a news hour made in Scotland.
- June 2018: Ofcom gives final approval, with an initial £32 million programme budget and core hours from 7pm to midnight.
- 24 February 2019: BBC Scotland launches, half originals and half repeats, after BBC Two Scotland leaves the air.
- 2024: The Nine is withdrawn and Ofcom agrees to cut peak-time news hours from 250 to 125.
- January 2025: Reporting Scotland: News at Seven, a 30-minute programme, replaces the news hour.
- 20 October 2026: the BBC says the linear channel will close in Spring 2027 and News at Seven will not move to iPlayer.
The news hour was the proof of seriousness in 2017. By 2024 it was the first thing the BBC asked Ofcom for permission to shrink. The regulator said a smaller peak quota could still meet the mission if more news moved online. That ruling is the dress rehearsal for this month’s decision: the live channel is treated as a pipe, not as the service.
BBC ALBA, which remains a linear channel, reached 43% of the Gaelic community each week in 2025/26, down from 47%. A targeted station can still hold its audience. BBC Scotland, aimed at the whole nation and parked next to BBC One, did not.
News at Seven Dies With the Slot
The one programme the BBC will not transfer is the nightly news show that now sits in the wreckage of The Nine. Reporting Scotland: News at Seven will stop when the linear channel stops. McAllan called that “a totally unacceptable reduction in nationally relevant journalism”. Head of news Howard Simpson said losing a programme brand is hard and that the show had brought viewers closer to the day’s news.
Hayley Valentine, BBC Scotland director and the launch editor of The Nine, said she was proud of the News at Seven team. She also said the rest of the news offer stays in place: Reporting Scotland on BBC One, The Sunday Show, Radio Scotland Breakfast, Scotcast and Debate Night.
WHAT STOPS AND WHAT STAYS
- Linear BBC Scotland: Leaves live television in Spring 2027 and continues as an iPlayer channel.
- News at Seven: Ends with the linear service and will not move online.
- Reporting Scotland: Remains on BBC One Scotland, with radio and digital news untouched by this decision.
- Debate Night, Scotcast and The Sunday Show: Continue across television, audio and digital.
- About 10 posts: Close on top of 60 BBC Scotland roles already announced this year.
That list is the honest ledger. Most of the channel’s factual series, sport and comedy can live on other BBC screens. A 7pm Scottish news programme made for that screen cannot, because the BBC has chosen not to give it a new home.
Hours, Jobs and the Linear Viewers Left Behind
Scotland still pays a full licence. The standard colour fee is £174.50, and the BBC estimates Scotland contributed £313 million in 2025/26, up from £311 million. Total spend booked to Scotland, after a transmission adjustment, was £278 million, which is 88.8% of the income raised there. McAllan set that ratio against 110.2% in Wales and 99% in Northern Ireland, and she put the gap between Welsh and Gaelic language funding at about £95 million.
BBC MONEY BOOKED TO SCOTLAND
| Line | 2025/26 | 2024/25 |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated licence income from Scotland | £313 million | £311 million |
| Total spend booked to Scotland | £278 million | £267 million |
| Scotland-originated “Watch” content | £65 million | £80 million |
| Network “Watch” made in Scotland | £96 million | £80 million |
| Total Scotland content spend | £116 million | £131 million |
Network production in Scotland rose while dedicated Scotland screen spend fell. The live channel ran 1,883 hours in 2025/26, including repeats, down from 1,917. BBC One Scotland opt-outs rose slightly to 695 hours. The corporation is trying to cut 1,800 to 2,000 jobs across the UK. In Scotland the extra cut tied to this switch is about 10 posts.
McAllan is right that some households will not follow the shows onto iPlayer. Ofcom still records a majority weekly linear audience, even as it falls. Superfast broadband now reaches 97% of Scottish homes, which is not the same as everyone choosing to sign in. The people most exposed are older viewers who use the news at a fixed hour on a television set, not the viewers already bingeing Inside Barlinnie on a phone.
What Ofcom Can Do
Ofcom can hold the BBC to its mission and public purposes. It cannot, on its own words, order the board to keep a named linear channel. An Ofcom spokesperson said decisions about closing a service are a matter for the BBC Board, and that the regulator “will be engaging with the BBC to understand how it plans to serve audiences across the UK” and will reply to McAllan in due course.
WHAT WE KNOW
- The legal owner: Closing a BBC service is a board decision, not a Holyrood one, and broadcasting stays reserved to Westminster.
- The licence test: Ofcom’s job is whether Scottish audiences remain well served, not whether channel 9 survives on Freeview.
- The last ruling: The regulator already halved the channel’s peak news quota and treated online news as a valid substitute.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- Any halt: There is no public sign Ofcom will try to keep the linear stream on air until Spring 2027.
- A public consultation: McAllan asked for a chance for Scottish viewers to be heard; Ofcom has not said it will run one.
- The next news hour: No replacement slot on BBC One or BBC Two has been offered for News at Seven.
McAllan also asked the regulator to weigh representation, plurality and “democratic engagement”, not just the drift to iPlayer. That is a request for a political reading of a budget cut. The 2024 news-quota decision suggests Ofcom will read it as an audience-habits case first.
A Friday Night Championship Slot on BBC Two
Valentine’s defence is that Scottish television is moving, not vanishing. BBC Two in Scotland, blanked as a national opt-out when the dedicated channel launched, will again carry Scotland-only programmes. Friday night SPFL Championship football is due to live there. BBC One Scotland keeps Scotland’s Home of the Year, Disclosure, Murder Case, Inside Barlinnie, the Scottish Cup final and Hogmanay. Louise Thornton, head of commissioning, pointed to network titles such as Two Doors Down as proof that Scottish shows already travel beyond the local button.
By continuing the channel on BBC iPlayer, we can ensure Scottish content thrives in a digital environment, while BBC Two in Scotland, alongside BBC One Scotland, will maintain a strong and distinctive Scottish presence on linear television.
Hayley Valentine, BBC Scotland Director, BBC media statement
The week the closure was confirmed, Highland Cops put that claim on a graph. Ratings from Digital-i, circulated by analyst Liam Hamilton, put a series four episode at more than 150,000 on BBC Scotland, the channel’s best audience of the year, then about 700,000 when BBC Two ran it across the UK. The dedicated slot still had a pulse. The network repeat had a crowd.
McAllan’s Commonwealth Games complaint sits in the same split. She said Scottish viewers could not watch the Glasgow Games on BBC One Scotland. Ofcom’s Scotland report notes that BBC ALBA carried live coverage from 23 July to 2 August 2026. The sport was on a BBC screen. It was not on the screen she is defending.
The letter will get a reply. It will not put channel 9 back in the guide. News at Seven still ends with the linear service in Spring 2027, and that is the cut that does not have an iPlayer substitute.
-
AUTO2 months agoVolkswagen Sells the Osnabruck Plant to Clear a Board Fight
-
NEWS3 months agoApple’s Foldable iPhone Hinges on Samsung Display Supply
-
BUSINESS3 months agoSaksham Gaur Finds He Is His Own Company’s Client
-
AUTO3 months agoTata Motors’ Iveco Tender Opens as Holders Still Decide
-
TECHNOLOGY3 years agoWhat Is SD on Amazon Prime?
-
BUSINESS3 months agoHyderabad 22-Carat Gold Jumps After a False Bargain
-
GAMING3 months agoOnimusha Way of the Sword Preload Hits a Windows 11 Wall
-
BUSINESS3 months agoUltraTech Ultravolt Launch Splits Friday Stocks to Watch
