Connect with us

LIFESTYLE

Dumbarton Witches: Who Was Accused and What the Records Show

Dumbarton witches were accused from 1624 to 1697. The burgh bills show who was strangled and burned, and which names still have no recorded fate.

Published

on

The ground behind Church Street in Dumbarton is a council car park today. Campaigners say people accused of witchcraft were led there to be killed in the seventeenth century. If you have come for the Dumbarton witches, the burgh’s own bills are what tie some of those names to a burning, and a printed outcome is only as strong as the bill behind it.

Louise Wilson, who lives in Alexandria and is secretary of Remembering the Accused Witches of Scotland, has been working through the Dumbarton common good accounts and the burgh records at the town library. The pages below give the names that went to the council, the cases where a bill describes a fire, a rope or a blank, the two places on the modern street, and what the national database can say about one person.

How the Dumbarton Burgh Accounts Name the Accused

Before those local volumes were read for this search, the first person usually named for Dumbarton was Jonet Boyd in 1628. The common good accounts, which run from 1614, and the burgh records, which run from 1627 to 1746, place four accusations in April 1624. Wilson set the early finds down in her notes on the Dumbarton burgh accounts, including six names she says had not been documented before.

These books are not a minute of verdicts. They are the town paying its way: a watcher in the tolbooth, a boy sent for paperwork, peat and coal for a fire, timber and tar, new stocks, ropes and nails. When a burning is secure in the record, it shows up as something the burgh bought.

In April 1624 the accounts pay John Sempill’s boy to go to Borrowstounness, the town now called Bo’ness, to extract the process against the witches. In June they pay for new stocks, ropes and nails for the witches burnt that month. A separate line buys coals and peats to burn Marioun Fallisdaill and Marioun MacLintock after their conviction. Fallisdaill was the widow of a burgess named Tarbet. MacLintock was the wife of Patrick Allan, also a burgess. Those two are the clearest executions in the early book.

Jonet MacKinley, a widow, is named on a line for ropes to bind the witches, and she was held in the tolbooth. Wilson writes that you can guess she was executed, and that no line records the proof. Her son, John Taylor, is not mentioned again, and Wilson assumes he was let go. The public list that followed is firmer on her than that note, and softer on him.

Dumbarton Witches Named on the August 2025 List

In August 2025 a motion to remember the accused witches of West Dunbartonshire went before the council, brought by SNP councillor Chris Pollok. With it came a list of 31 people, 27 women and 4 men, drawn from Wilson’s research. This is that roster, with the outcome words printed beside each name.

HOW TO READ AN OUTCOME

  • Executed: The motion list treats this person as put to death.
  • Unknown: The list leaves the fate blank, which is not a recorded acquittal.
  • Absconded: The person left, and the list does not add a later execution.

The labels add up to 21 marked executed, nine left unknown, and one man marked as having absconded. Those totals describe the printed list. They do not describe every bill, because two executed labels sit on names Wilson had already described more cautiously. Jonet MacKinley’s label is firmer than her note, which says the proof of a burning was not found. Jonet Ewing, in 1650, is the other.

Year Name Outcome on the August 2025 List
1624 Jonet MacKinley Executed
1624 Marioun MacLintock Executed
1624 Marioun Fallisdaill Executed
1624 John Taylor Unknown
1628 Jonet Boyd Executed
1628 Marioun MacLintock Unknown
1628 Janet Weill Unknown
1629 Janet Donald Executed
1629 Jonet Neill Executed
1629 Margaret Hunter Unknown
1630 Janet Mitchell Unknown
1632 Lord John Colquhoun Absconded
1632 Thomas Carlipis Unknown
1643 Bessie Bargillie Executed
1649 Margaret Corruith Executed
1649 Jonet Davisonne Executed
1649 Agnes McKen Executed
1650 Jonet Patersone Executed
1650 Margaret McMurich Executed
1650 Jonet McClintock Unknown
1650 Jonet Colquhoun Executed
1650 Margaret McInlay Executed
1650 Jonet Ewing Executed
1650 Jonet Stewart Unknown
1656 John McWilliam Executed
1671 Jonet Howat Unknown
1677 Margaret Wright Executed
1677 Issobell Laing Executed
1677 Jonet Munn Executed
1677 Margaret Paterson Executed
1697 Margaret McKillope Executed

Ewing was the wife of Johne Porter, also written Johne Pirter, in Glen. The 1650 accounts pay 5s 6d for nails for a vault door to hold her, a warrant putting her to trial, and a watcher. Wilson says the missing burgh book leaves her fate unknown. The August list marks her executed anyway.

By 29 October 2025 the count had moved again. Wilson said she had found 32 cases linked to Dumbarton from 1624 to 1697, with 22 of those people executed. Of the other 10, one had fled and the fates of the other nine were not in the records she had. The extra person is not named on the August list, so the two totals belong side by side until a revised roster is published.

Four Dumbarton Cases the Accounts Describe

Once the roster is in front of you, four cases show the range better than either total. One begins with a street quarrel, one is a second woman with a familiar surname, one has a stake and a bill, and one is a man whose year does not match across the tellings.

Jonet Boyd and a Quarrel in the Street

Jonet Boyd was accused in 1628 by Robert Glen, a notary. He said he met her in the street, that she swore at him, caught his cloak, whipped him around and threw a stone, and that two witnesses agreed. The next morning he accused her of witchcraft. Wilson notes that the papers do not say whether Glen had done anything to her first, and Boyd was executed on that accusation.

“These were ordinary people doing ordinary jobs, but if you argue with your neighbour you could end up accused of witchcraft,” says Wilson. She adds that port towns produced many accusations of this kind, because a failed crop, a bad trading spell or a ship in trouble could be laid at a neighbour’s door, in Dumbarton as on the Fife coast and in Ayr.

Two Women Called Marioun MacLintock

The 1624 Marioun MacLintock is the burgess’s wife burned with Marioun Fallisdaill. Four years later the accounts and the privy council papers show another Marioun MacLintock accused, and someone paid to cut and comb her hair while searching for the Devil’s mark. They do not say what happened after that search.

  • 1624 Marioun: Coals and peats were bought to burn her after conviction, with Marioun Fallisdaill.
  • 1628 Marioun: A mark search is recorded, and no burning, acquittal or release is recorded after it.

Wilson treats them as two people, most likely relatives. Folding the surname into one woman would turn a documented burning and an unfinished case into a single fate.

Bessie Bargillie and the Town’s Bill

In 1643 the accounts take Bessie Bargillie’s belongings, sold for the charges of her trial and execution, at 37 lib 13s. They also pay a messenger for summoning the assize and for putting up the stoup, the stake at which she was wirryit, meaning strangled, and afterwards burned. The burgh volume is missing for 1641 to 1651, so the words of the accusation are gone, and no husband is named for her.

Strangling and then the fire is the method named in 120 of the 141 Scottish sentences that record one.

  • 120 sentences specify strangling and burning.
  • 17 specify burning, and many of those people may have been strangled first.
  • 3 specify beheading, where another crime was also charged.
  • 1 specifies hanging, also with another crime in the case.

A very small number of people are known to have been burned alive. Bessie’s bill matches the ordinary method, not that rarer one.

John McWilliam and a Date That Differs

John McWilliam was a slater. Wilson describes a second accusation, a flight to Stranraer, a trial in Edinburgh and an execution in 1655. The August 2025 list dates him to 1656 and marks him executed. Both tellings come through her research, and they do not agree on the year.

  1. Second accusation: He had already been accused once before he fled.
  2. Stranraer: He left Dumbarton for Stranraer after that second accusation.
  3. Edinburgh: He was tried there, rather than only in the burgh.
  4. 1655 or 1656: Her later account dates the execution to 1655, and the motion list dates the case to 1656.

Until those two years are tied to one record, both dates belong in any careful account of him. Lord John Colquhoun, marked as absconded in 1632, is the clearest flight on the August list, and he should not be merged with McWilliam, who is counted among the executed.

The Tollbooth and the Church Street Ground

With the names in hand, the next question is where in the modern town any of this happened. Two pins get mentioned, and they are not the same claim. The seventeenth-century tolbooth stood near the entrance to the Artizan Centre, directly opposite Quay Street. That is where people were held. The accounts pay for watchers, for stocks, and for nails to a vault door.

The execution ground is a separate claim. It is thought to lie behind Church Street, in what is now the council office car park, and that is the ground where the charity wants a memorial. In August 2020 West Dunbartonshire’s heritage service said just under 20 people in Dumbarton and the Vale of Leven had been accused, and that those found guilty were burned at the tolbooth, with the Artizan Centre now standing on that ground.

The 2020 figure covers the burgh plus the Vale, at an earlier stage of the search. It should not be subtracted from the later burgh totals to invent a remainder. The local history service has also said it holds a charter from James VI telling the bailies of Dumbarton to seek and apprehend anyone suspected of witchcraft, which is why the town, and not only the kirk, appears all through the bills.

How Sure Is a Scottish Witchcraft Execution Rate?

The local blanks make more sense once you see how thin the national sentence record is. The Witchcraft Act was in force from 1563 to 1736. It was repealed in 1736, when a new offence of pretended witchcraft carried at most a year’s prison, after a last prosecution in 1727. You can read how the Survey of Scottish Witchcraft was built at the University of Edinburgh if you want the project behind the national names.

The count there is 3,837 people accused, 3,212 of them named, plus 625 unnamed people or groups. Older round numbers, including claims of many thousands executed, sit outside that researched total.

A known trial sentence survives for only 305 of the named people. The split is worth keeping in one place, because a headline often turns it into a single fraction and stops.

  • 205 were to be executed.
  • 52 were acquitted.
  • 27 were banished.
  • 11 were declared fugitive.
  • 6 were excommunicated.
  • 2 were outlawed.
  • 1 was to be kept in prison.
  • 1 was to be publicly humiliated.

A further 98 people were recorded as having fled, and that figure sits outside the 305 known sentences.

On those 305 sentences alone, the executed share is 67%, or about two-thirds. The Survey’s answers on how many people were executed say that share is probably not very accurate, because it rests on less than a tenth of the named accused.

The 305 are an odd slice in two directions at once. Most of them come from the central justiciary court, which probably acquitted a higher share than local courts did, and most trials were local. The wider list also includes people only investigated by the church, some of whom never reached a criminal court. One problem would push the death rate up. The other would pull it down. Neither makes 67% a settled fact.

Most of the accused were women: 84%, with 15% men, and sex unrecorded for the remaining 1%. The August Dumbarton list, with 27 women and 4 men, sits in that same pattern. The four men are John Taylor, Lord John Colquhoun, Thomas Carlipis and John McWilliam.

Of the named accused, 32% came from the Lothians and 14% from Strathclyde and the west. Dumbarton belongs to that smaller western share. Haddingtonshire, today’s East Lothian, was the hardest hunted county.

The heavy national years were 1590 to 1591, 1597, 1628 to 1630, 1649, and 1661 to 1662, and they were local bursts rather than one sweep of the country. Dumbarton touches two of those windows, in 1628 to 1630 and again in 1649 to 1650. The 1624 burnings come before that run of peaks, and the four 1677 names sit outside it.

Where the papers are full enough, the evidence was a confession, often after the person had been kept from sleep, plus neighbours’ stories of a quarrel followed by a misfortune, names offered by other suspects, or a search for the Devil’s mark. Sleep deprivation was the usual pressure, often applied by burgh bailies or kirk elders, and before 1662 it was rarely called torture. About ten professional witch-prickers are known to have worked in Scotland, pricking for an insensitive spot.

A kirk session could question a suspect. It could not carry out an execution, so the case had to pass to a criminal court. Most people were tried in a one-off local court under a commission from the privy council or parliament, and few of those transcripts survive. What often remains is the commission itself or, as in Dumbarton, the town’s receipts.

The Dumbarton Memorial Plan as of October 2025

On 8 March 2022, speaking in the Scottish Parliament on International Women’s Day, Nicola Sturgeon offered a formal apology for prosecutions under the 1563 act.

“Today on International Women’s Day, as first minister on behalf of the Scottish government, I am choosing to acknowledge that egregious historic injustice and extend a formal posthumous apology to all of those accused, convicted, vilified or executed under the Witchcraft Act of 1563.”

Nicola Sturgeon, First Minister of Scotland, Scottish Parliament, 8 March 2022

She also said parliament could choose to pass a pardon. The speech itself did not do that. Locally, the memorial is a proposal dated by the talks rather than by a stone. As of October 2025, a West Dunbartonshire Council spokesperson said: “We have been engaging with Remembering the Accused Witches of Scotland who are keen to install a fitting memorial.”

The site in those talks is the car park off Church Street. When Pollok’s motion was heard, councillors agreed that the accused in each ward should be remembered. The October 2025 comment gave no date for setting a stone.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do You Search the Survey for a Dumbarton Name?

You search the Survey of Scottish Witchcraft by name, place and date, and you can download the whole database for your own checks. A blank page does not clear someone. Names drawn out of the Dumbarton common good accounts were missing from the older national lists, so the town’s bills remain the place to look when the database has no line.

Did Scotland Use the Swimming Test on Accused Witches?

Scotland almost never used the water test shown in films. The Survey records it once, early in the prosecutions, for an unknown number of suspects, and it has found no evidence the test was used again after that episode was discredited. Ropes were tied to the people in the water so they could be pulled out. Nothing in the Dumbarton accounts describes a swimming.

Did the 2022 Apology Pardon the Dumbarton Accused?

No pardon was issued with the apology. In 2022 Nicola Sturgeon, then first minister, apologised on behalf of the Scottish government to people accused, convicted, vilified or executed under the Witchcraft Act. She told members of parliament they could choose to legislate for a pardon, which is a separate step the apology did not take.

Were Accused Witches Mostly Old Widows?

Where an age was recorded, about half of the accused were over 40, and the Survey has no age for most people. Where marital status was recorded, 78% of the women were married and 19% were widowed, but a wife’s status was more likely to be written down than a widow’s, so those shares are probably skewed. Neighbours often treated a reputation as years old by the time of a trial.

The coals and peats bought in June 1624 to burn Marioun Fallisdaill and Marioun MacLintock, and the stake set up in 1643 where Bessie Bargillie was strangled and then burned, are lines a memorial can quote without guessing. Other names on the August 2025 list wait on a line of that kind.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of CUMBERNAULD MEDIA, which he runs as an independent publication after a decade in journalism spent moving from reporting to editing. His habit is to open the document before the summary of it. A company result is read from the filing rather than the press release, a court or regulatory decision from the judgment itself, a scientific finding from the paper and its methods section rather than the headline claim, and a sporting sanction from the governing body's own ruling. That approach shapes coverage across news, business and technology as much as science, sports and entertainment, and it carries into the lifestyle, travel, auto and gaming pages, where product specifications are checked against the manufacturer's sheet and, where possible, against Harry's own testing. Every number is checked before publication, and where a source's figures are disputed the story says so. Corrections follow a public policy and are marked on the page. Readers anywhere in the world who write in get a reply from him, and the address is support@cumbernauld-media.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending