Connect with us

BUSINESS

Private-Sector Influence in an Independent Scotland: Who Should Own What

Private-sector influence in an independent Scotland is too much when people cannot leave a supplier the state cannot replace. Use this test on water.

Published

on

You are trying to judge how much of an independent Scotland should sit in private hands, and the argument usually arrives as a slogan. One side wants firms to run almost every service. The other wants ministers to take the utilities back.

Private-sector influence becomes a problem when a firm controls a service you cannot leave, and the public cannot step in if that firm fails or walks away. A large private sector of shops, farms, workshops and software firms is a normal part of a mixed economy.

This page sets out what that mix already looks like in Scotland, why a big spending total is not the same thing as a big public workforce, which services are already public, and a test you can apply to any industry. Currency comes after the ownership test, because it changes how public work is paid for.

What Does a Mixed Economy Look Like in Scotland?

A mixed economy is one in which private firms produce most everyday goods, while the state sets rules, raises taxes, pays benefits and runs the services that do not work well as a simple shop counter. Scotland already lives in that mix, whether or not it becomes an independent country.

You can see all three layers on one street. A bakery, a garage and a software firm sell to anyone who chooses them, and a rival can open nearby. A hospital and a primary school are funded so that the service does not depend on who can pay at the door. Between those two sits the contract layer, where a public body pays a private firm to supply food, software, care hours or a building.

THREE LAYERS IN THE SCOTTISH MIX

  • Open market: You can switch supplier, and a new firm can enter, as with food, clothes and most trades.
  • Public service: The state funds or owns the service because turning people away, or running two rival networks, works badly.
  • Bought-in work: A public budget pays a private firm, so the influence sits inside the public pound rather than outside it.

The third layer is the one slogan-heavy arguments miss. A country can employ a modest public workforce and still hand a large share of its public money to private owners. Scotland’s onshore economy was worth £219 billion in 2025, so the argument is about a large set of real transactions, not a diagram in a textbook.

Public Spending and the Public Sector in Scotland

Scotland’s public sector is larger than the UK average, and demand for health and care has pushed it that way, but it is not half the economy. A briefing on the size of Scotland’s economy, published by the Scottish Parliament on 1 July 2026, sets the public share of output and of jobs beside the UK figures. The spending rows come from the official 2025-26 accounts.

Measure Scotland UK Period
Public sector share of GVA 24.8% 19.5% 2023
Public sector share of employment 22.6% 18.0% 2025
Public spending as a share of GDP 53.1% 44.3% 2025-26
Spending per person £22,281 £19,561 2025-26

Read the spending row as a different quantity from the jobs row. The jobs row counts people employed by a public body. The spending row counts money spent for people in Scotland, including the state pension, other benefits and contracts with private firms. The official accounts say that spending-to-GDP ratio is not a measure of what the public sector contributes to output.

The employment share in that table was 601,600 people in December 2025, on the Scottish Government’s public sector employment statistics. In the public spending and revenue figures for 2025-26, spending for Scotland was £123.6 billion. Spending per person was £2,720 higher than the UK figure, which is 13.9%.

Of that December 2025 headcount, 91.7% sat in the devolved public sector, meaning councils, NHS Scotland and Scottish public bodies rather than UK departments. The reserved slice is small in jobs and large in money, because the state pension and a great deal of other social security are still paid from UK departments.

Which Scottish Services Are Already Public?

You do not need a future constitution to see a public-private line. Several services already sit on one side of it, and the awkward cases sit in between. Start with the ones a household meets every week.

How Is Scottish Water Owned?

Scottish Water is a public corporation. It supplies household water and wastewater to more than 90% of the population, under the Water Industry (Scotland) Act 2002, and it is accountable to Scottish ministers through the Scottish Parliament. It is also commercially run and independently regulated, and its surpluses are reinvested rather than paid out to shareholders.

  • Who pays: Customer charges, plus government borrowing, fund the network.
  • Who is outside it: About 3.5% of the population relies on small private supplies, mostly in remote rural areas.
  • What it does not prove: Public ownership removes dividends, and it does not remove the need for investment or the bills that fund it.

Public water and sewerage are private in England and Wales. In the Scottish accounts, that difference explains slightly less than one percentage point of Scotland’s higher spending per person. The model is a public balance sheet with a regulator, not a government department turning a tap.

Health, Schools and the Care Split

Hospital care and schools are funded as public services, and nearly all of the health and education lines in the 2025-26 accounts are devolved. NHS employment in Scotland stood at 190,300 in December 2025. Social care is the sharp private case, because a stay in a care home is hard to switch in the week a family needs it.

The STUC puts the leak from the largest private care homes at up to £28 in every £100, counting profit, rent, director pay and interest on loans together. That is a wider drain than a profit margin on a bakery, because the payer is often a public budget and the user may have no second home to move to that month.

Electricity Ownership Under the Scotland Act

Electricity is the service people most often assume would flip to public hands on independence day. Under devolution it cannot, because the Scotland Act 1998 reserves it. The Act’s reservation of electricity generation and supply covers generation, transmission, distribution and supply, and the law that privatised the industry.

You can change electricity supplier. You cannot choose a second set of wires to your street, and those wires are not owned by a Scottish public corporation in the way Scottish Water is. Wind farms and other generators are private businesses selling into a GB market that Scottish ministers do not control.

Independence is the moment that reservation would fall. Ownership of farms and of the grid would then be a choice for a Scottish Parliament, not a power the current devolution settlement already hands to ministers. A community stake in one development is a different decision from taking the national network into public hands.

What Does Public Money Buy From Private Firms?

A large part of private influence never shows up as a privatised utility. It shows up as an invoice. Research on the cost of outsourcing, prepared for the STUC by the Association for Public Service Excellence and dated November 2025, put Scottish public sector external spend at about £16 billion a year, out of public expenditure it counted at £111 billion.

The same research gives a conservative estimate that £2 billion to £3 billion a year leaves through profit and other ways private owners take money out of that spend. The £111 billion base is the report’s own frame, not the £123.6 billion spending total in the later 2025-26 accounts, so the two figures should not be forced into one ratio.

Bought-in work is not automatically a bad buy. A council that hires a builder for a school extension is using the private sector for a job with an end date. The risk grows when the firm holds a system the public cannot pause, including the private contract keeping Scottish benefits live. Households cannot switch the payer of their benefit, so the state’s ability to take the system back matters more than the logo on the supplier.

QUESTIONS ON A PUBLIC CONTRACT

  • The exit: Ask whether staff, data and kit return to the public body if the firm leaves.
  • The margin: Ask how much of the fee is wages on the job, and how much leaves as profit, rent or interest.
  • The user: Ask whether the person receiving the service can refuse that provider.

Council procurement has been rising faster than councils’ own wage bills in the STUC’s local government work, which is a reason to read the contract rather than the press release. A service staffed mostly by women, as care and many facilities jobs are, carries the pay cut if the contract competes on wages.

Which Jobs Stay With the State?

Every mixed economy gives the state the same short list of jobs. Independence would move some of them from Westminster to Holyrood. It would not delete the list. The useful question is which job is already Scottish, and which job an independent state would have to pick up.

Job of the state Where it sits for Scotland
Set market rules Consumer protection and many care rules are devolved. Electricity licensing is reserved.
Provide public goods Schools, roads and most hospital care are devolved. Defence is reserved.
Redistribute income Some payments, including the Scottish Child Payment, are devolved. The state pension is still paid by the UK.
Steady the economy The Scottish Parliament sets some taxes. The Bank of England sets the interest rate while Scotland uses sterling.
Deal with spillover costs Pollution control is largely devolved. The design of the electricity market is reserved.
Own critical networks Water is a public corporation. The power grid is not.
Back long projects Public bodies invest, and private finance is still used for some public buildings.
Protect property and contracts Courts and registers make private trade possible. Without them the market layer fails.
Handle trade Treaties and tariffs are reserved. Independence would move that job to Edinburgh.

In 2025-26, devolved spending was £75.1 billion and reserved spending was £48.5 billion. Social protection was the largest block of the total, at £36.5 billion, and health was next at £21.1 billion. An independent budget would have to carry the reserved social security and debt interest that now sit on the UK side, which is a fiscal choice separate from who owns a pipe.

How to Judge Private-Sector Influence

Once you can see the three layers, the test is short enough to use on a single service. Apply it before you decide that private owners have gone too far, or that a ministry should take a firm over.

THREE QUESTIONS BEFORE YOU CALL IT TOO MUCH

  1. Switch: Can a household change supplier this month without moving house?
  2. Replace: If the firm stopped, could a public body take over the pipes, the data or the staff?
  3. Surplus: Do the profit and the loss land on users, on taxpayers, or on owners outside Scotland?

A weekly shop fails the charge of too much private influence, because you can change supermarket and a new shop can open. The water at the kitchen tap meets the case for a public provider, because there is one pipe and Scottish Water already fills that role for most people. A private bakery does not become a public problem because the owner makes a profit.

Electricity is the middle case. You can change the company named on the bill, and you cannot change the wires. A private wind farm can sit on the open-market side of the test. The grid sits with water, on the side where a public owner or a very hard public duty belongs. A care home place sits there too when a relative has no second vacancy that week, which is why price, staffing and the right to move need a public backstop even if a private or charitable owner runs the building.

There is a third ownership form between a ministry and a listed company. Social enterprises, employee-owned firms and co-ops put a business in the hands of workers, users or a community. They suit a local care service or a community energy scheme. A co-op that is the only supplier in town is still a single supplier, so the same three questions still apply.

Currency and Paying for Public Work

Ownership answers who runs the service. Currency answers how an independent state pays for the services it keeps, and whether it must ask private investors to fund public assets. Those are linked, and they are not the same decision.

The Scottish Government’s plan to move to a Scottish pound, set out in its October 2022 economic prospectus, keeps sterling in the early years so wages, pensions and shop prices do not change on day one. A new Scottish central bank would advise on when a Scottish pound was ready, and the Scottish Parliament would decide. There is no fixed calendar date in that plan.

While sterling is the currency, the Bank of England still sets the interest rate that mortgages and business loans follow. Scotland could tax, spend and regulate. It could not set the price of money. A separate currency is what would let a Scottish central bank do that job, and it is also what critics of a long sterling period treat as the condition for funding public work without leaning on private owners.

The same prospectus proposes a Building a New Scotland Fund of up to £20 billion over the first decade, aimed at infrastructure such as warmer homes, cleaner transport and housing. That is a public investment plan inside the sterling period, not a programme for taking the energy grid into public ownership. People who want a Scottish pound from the first day are arguing about monetary power. People who want the wires in public hands are arguing about the grid. A vote on one does not settle the other.

Frequently Asked Questions

Would Independence Put Energy in Public Hands?

No. Independence would remove the Scotland Act reservation on electricity, and a Scottish Parliament could then decide who owns generation and the grid. The Scottish Government’s prospectus does not set out a takeover of existing wind farms or of the network. It does talk about communities taking direct stakes in local developments, which is a smaller step than a national energy company.

Does GERS Show the Cost of Independence?

No. The notional gap in 2025-26 was £25.3 billion, and the Scottish Government says those accounts describe Scotland inside the UK, not the books of a separate state. Defence, debt interest, tax and pension design would all be choices after independence, so the same gap is not a bill you can carry forward unchanged. What the accounts do show is higher spending per person, not a revenue take per person far below the UK.

Can Scotland Keep the Pound and Still Steer the Economy?

It can steer tax, spending and regulation, and it cannot set the interest rate. Under the official plan, sterling stays until a Scottish central bank advises that a Scottish pound is ready and Parliament agrees. In that sterling phase, mortgages and business loans still follow a rate set in London. A separate currency is the tool that moves that rate to Scotland.

Are Co-ops a Middle Path in a Mixed Economy?

They can be the owner without being a ministry. A Scottish Government review published on 3 September 2024, written to meet a commitment in the National Strategy for Economic Transformation, treats social enterprises, employee-owned firms and co-ops as part of how the economy is owned, not as a side scheme. If a co-op is the only care provider in a town, you still want a public rule on price, quality and what happens if it closes.

What Happens to Savings if the Currency Changes?

Under the official plan, wages, pensions and shop prices stay in sterling during the transition, so deposits do not convert on day one. A plan for a Scottish pound from the first day has to say how bank deposits and mortgages convert, and at what rate, before you can judge it. No guide can tell you what a future Parliament will pass.

If you are sorting one service this week, start with the pipe, the wires, the care bed or the payment system, and ask who can walk away. A shop does not meet that test for too much private influence. A network that people cannot leave does.

Disclaimer: This guide is an educational overview of Scotland’s public and private economy, and it is informational only. It is not legal advice, tax advice or a forecast of what an independent Scotland would pass into law. Questions about a contract, a pension, a currency change or a public takeover belong with a qualified solicitor, accountant or regulated adviser, and in public life with elected institutions. Figures and legal rules reflect the sources cited here as published at the time of review, and they can be revised.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of CUMBERNAULD MEDIA, which he runs as an independent publication after a decade in journalism spent moving from reporting to editing. His habit is to open the document before the summary of it. A company result is read from the filing rather than the press release, a court or regulatory decision from the judgment itself, a scientific finding from the paper and its methods section rather than the headline claim, and a sporting sanction from the governing body's own ruling. That approach shapes coverage across news, business and technology as much as science, sports and entertainment, and it carries into the lifestyle, travel, auto and gaming pages, where product specifications are checked against the manufacturer's sheet and, where possible, against Harry's own testing. Every number is checked before publication, and where a source's figures are disputed the story says so. Corrections follow a public policy and are marked on the page. Readers anywhere in the world who write in get a reply from him, and the address is support@cumbernauld-media.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending