Connect with us

NEWS

Samsung TV Tracking Claims Fit Years of ACR

A 2025 Tizen root dump, a five-second mic test and a lab study sit on Samsung’s own ACR notices and a February Texas consent deal.

Published

on

Log4j, a reverse engineer and bug-bounty hunter, said on October 21, 2026 that his 2025 Samsung TV tracks viewing and can capture audio. He rooted the set after ads felt too precise, then posted code from Tizen. Samsung has not commented on the thread.

Screen tracking of this kind already has a name inside the set, a Texas consent deal from February, and a university lab that watched ACR-like traffic continue after the official off switch. The new pieces are a soundbar-as-mic path, bark-and-cry counters in telemetry, and a five-second microphone test that still does not prove a live room tap.

A Root Shell and a File Named security-policy.xml

The first post was blunt. “I own a relatively new (2025) samsung tv. i kept getting weirdly targeted ads,” he wrote, adding that the firmware was AES-encrypted, so he used zero-day bugs for a root shell and “discovered PRIVACY HORROR.” He priced the set at $3,000.

always on hot mic functionality btw. PLUS: automatic content recognition, geo positioning, network mapping, a targeted ads service, 4 distinct drm services, user profile building and so much more juicy telemetry! just you, God, a $3000 TV and samsung + their 400 partners!

log4j, reverse engineer, on X, October 21, 2026

The screenshot under that post was a file called security-policy.xml. Later posts named a service styled rmdemon (demon, not daemon) that he said starts a packet logger on the local network. He also described a region-specific model, files he labelled LogoCNN.bin and cnn.mapping, that watches in-app behaviour on YouTube: videos played, ads skipped, and how far a title runs.

WHAT THE ROOT SHELL SHOWED

  • Screen tracking: Automatic content recognition plus screenshots sit in the same stack as ads and a cross-device advertising ID.
  • Audio path: He said the set classifies what it hears, then reports dog-barking and baby-crying event counters, camera streaming duration, and sensor flags such as EV201/SOUNDSENSOR_ON.
  • Borrowed mics: If the chassis has no microphone, he wrote, it looks for one on a soundbar or a Bluetooth device and ships that audio to Bixby.
  • In-app model: The convolutional net is separate from HDMI fingerprinting; it scores what happens inside apps, not only what an antenna or a stick puts on the glass.
  • The toggle: On October 25 he warned that turning ACR off in preferences “should not be assumed to actually disable ACR telemetry,” and asked journalists to request his full report rather than infer from a live decompile.

He is still writing that report, in two layers, one technical and one meant so other owners can repeat the work. He also said he wants a custom flash that drops Samsung’s own data pipes while leaving Netflix and YouTube as they are. Until that lands, the public file is a thread, not a lab paper.

Samsung Already Sells a Feature That Hears Barking

A lot of the “horror” is on the box. Samsung’s US support page says a Smart TV may use Automatic Content Recognition if the owner agreed by opting in to Viewing Information Services at setup. ACR, it says, builds signatures of viewership. The list is viewing history (shows watched and time spent), a Personalized Service ID, and an IP address. The same page says Samsung “does not record or watch any of the content displayed on your Smart TV,” and that the feature applies to all Samsung Smart TVs and can be switched in Settings.

Texas described a faster cadence when it sued. A January 2026 restraining-order release said the company’s ACR captured screenshots every 500 milliseconds. That is twice a second, used to fingerprint whatever is on the glass, including HDMI, not a person sitting on the sofa with a camera.

Barking is an advertised product too. At CES 2025 Samsung rolled Pet Care and Family Care into Vision AI sets, using the camera and microphone to spot pets and people and to ping SmartThings. Pet Care, as Samsung describes it, listens for a dog while the TV is off and plugged in, then alerts the phone. Family Care is sold around falls and other household events. Product copy talks about barking. It does not advertise a baby-crying counter sent home as telemetry, which is the extra claim in the October thread.

So the fight is not whether Tizen can hear a dog. It can, on models that ship that kit, and Samsung will sell you the alert. The open question is what leaves the living room after the classifier runs, and whether a set with no built-in mic will quietly open a soundbar instead.

Texas Forced Consent Screens in February

This argument is older than the 2025 chassis. On February 6, 2017, Vizio Inc. agreed to pay $2.2 million to settle charges from the Federal Trade Commission and New Jersey that it collected viewing histories on 11 million smart TVs without consent. The complaint said the sets captured second-by-second information from cable, antenna, DVD, and streaming, then helped append age, income, and household size for ads across devices. Vizio had billed the setting as “Smart Interactivity.”

THE ACR PAPER TRAIL

  1. February 6, 2017: Vizio agrees to the $2.2 million FTC and New Jersey order ($1.5 million to the FTC and $1 million to New Jersey, with $300,000 of the state sum suspended) and to delete data collected before March 1, 2016.
  2. December 2025: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sues Samsung, Sony, LG, Hisense, and TCL over ACR, arguing that “Viewing Information Services” hid the real job of the screenshot engine.
  3. January 6, 2026: A Texas court issues a temporary restraining order against Samsung, with the attorney general’s office saying the sets captured screenshots every 500 milliseconds.
  4. February 26, 2026: Samsung Electronics America agrees to stop collecting ACR viewing data from Texans without express consent and to ship “clear and conspicuous” disclosure screens.
  5. October 21, 2026: log4j posts the Tizen root shell and the privacy thread that is still circulating.
  6. October 25, 2026: He says the on-set ACR off switch should not be trusted, which matches what a Northeastern lab had just measured on Tizen.

The February pact required Samsung to halt any collection or processing of ACR viewing data unless Texas buyers give express consent. Paxton called Samsung one of the first makers to make the change and said suits against Sony, LG, Hisense, and TCL would go on. A Samsung spokesperson said at the time that Samsung TVs “do not spy on consumers” and that owners can change privacy settings at any time.

Texans must be fully informed about whether their data is collected and be in full control of how it’s used.

Ken Paxton, Texas attorney general, February 26, 2026 statement

Eight months later the same company had not answered a researcher who says the off switch is leaky and that a set without a mic will go looking for one. The February screens were about consent copy. They were not a claim that Tizen stopped fingerprinting HDMI or classifying household sound.

What Northeastern Found After the Opt-Out

Northeastern University researchers posted Watching the Watchers in October 2026, a privacy analysis of ACR on US smart TVs. They built a living-room testbed, played the same content on every set, and logged the packets. The headline numbers are 82% of US households with a smart TV that can snapshot the screen and report it, eight operating systems covering about 95% of the US market, and 5,943 controlled experiments on 12 televisions from 10 manufacturers, each run through 10 viewing situations with ACR on and again after the set’s own opt-out.

On Tizen, ACR is video-based. Traffic to the recognition servers died on a black frame; muting the sound changed nothing. Antenna, the built-in free stream, Tubi, and HDMI all produced content-correlated traffic when the feature was on. Netflix and YouTube did not, which matches the deals those apps are known to strike so the TV does not fingerprint their catalogues.

The opt-out is where Tizen diverged from LG’s webOS, Sony’s Google TV, VIDAA, and Fire TV, four platforms where the off switch fully quieted the identified ACR hosts. Most of that traffic is encrypted, so the lab scored it by timing, volume, and destination, not by reading a viewing log. The authors say they cannot confirm what the packets held, or whether anyone stored a history.

TIZEN AFTER THE OPT-OUT

Viewing situation Opted-out runs ACR-like traffic
Samsung built-in streaming 30 of 30 Yes, no drop
Antenna (two picture-on tests) 41 of 60 Yes, still present
HDMI 18 of 30 Yes, still present
Tubi 6 of 30 Yes, still present

Those cells are the same counts the researchers published in prose. After opt-out they also saw a little traffic in a few idle, Netflix, and YouTube runs, cases that were not tracked when ACR was on. Vizio’s SmartCast opt-out had no visible effect on its Amazon Kinesis ACR endpoint. Roku’s off switch does not cover Roku’s own free channel.

Put next to the October thread, the lab is the independent measurement log4j asked reporters not to invent from his decompile. He said the preference check is skipped or wrongly implemented in places. Northeastern, on one Samsung set and one firmware, saw the same shape: the menu said off, the ACR hosts still heard from the TV.

Five Seconds of Microphone, Then Silence

The line that travelled farthest was the borrowed mic. “If your samsung TV model doesnt have a microphone, it will look for connected devices with one, such as a soundbar or a connected bluetooth device. this gets shipped off to bixby,” log4j wrote on October 23. A follow-up said the set classifies audio before it reports back, with dog-barking and baby-crying counters on the telemetry path. He later joked that a misspelled CAMERASENOR_ON flag meant “a small spanish guy in your tv watching you.” He also said, at the end of the run, that he had “finally found a company that truly listens to its customers.”

Xuan-Son Nguyen, an engineer at Hugging Face who posts as ngxson, rooted his own Tizen set and tried to catch the mic in the act. He wrote a dummy USB microphone for Flipper Zero that enumerates as USB Audio Class 1.0, 16 kHz, mono, and plays quiet noise instead of sampling a real capsule. The README is careful: enumeration alone does not prove Bixby used the stream, and “TV behavior is not yet verified.”

On the set, he still saw a grab. “Ok so right off the bat, it opens the mic for exactly five seconds then stop. Seems like a strange way to test mic (?) Then no more recording since then, but need to keep observing more to conclude,” he wrote on October 23. He also said his TV was rooted and had many settings switched off, so a stock unit might differ. That is a probe, not a recording of a family dinner. It shows the USB host opened a capture device. It does not show storage, upload, or a wake-word buffer that never sleeps.

The louder version of the same posts, that the panel records everything while it is off, is the part the measurements do not carry. Pet Care is designed to hear a dog with the screen dark. ACR fingerprints glass, not chatter. The five-second USB open looks like a hardware check. None of those facts need a conspiracy to be ugly for people who clicked through setup and never found Viewing Information Services.

His OpenAI Ban Landed Before the Write-Up

While the thread ran, OpenAI deactivated log4j’s account for Cyber Abuse. He said he had not used the tools to attack the TV or hunt bugs, only to help with local reverse engineering, and that the hit cost him about $500 plus banked resets. On October 26 he walked that back a step. The ban, he wrote, “almost certainly had nothing to do with using openai -specifically- for my samsung reverse engineering work.” He thinks a hidden Daybreak tripwire treated blunt terms (memory, trampoline hooks, encrypted pages) like malware work, then poisoned later chats. The account stayed closed. He said he was moving to open-weight models on his own machines.

Samsung still had not answered him by October 27. Owners in the replies were not waiting for a white paper. They wanted the ACR toggle, a guest network, DNS filters, and, for people willing to live with a dumb panel, an Apple TV or Shield on HDMI with the Samsung SoC denied egress. That last setup is the honest end of this product: the glass is cheap because the viewing graph is the other SKU, and a rooted 2025 set just made the graph visible as XML.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • Named feature: Samsung documents ACR under Viewing Information Services and lists history, a Personalized Service ID, and IP as the payload.
  • Consent order: The February 26, 2026 Texas agreement requires express consent before ACR viewing data is collected from Texans.
  • Lab result: On the Tizen unit Northeastern tested, opt-out did not stop ACR-like traffic in the built-in stream, antenna, HDMI, or Tubi runs above.
  • Mic probe: A rooted set opened Nguyen’s dummy USB mic for five seconds, then went quiet for hours.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • Room audio: No public capture shows raw conversation leaving a stock Samsung TV.
  • Soundbar hijack: Code paths are claimed; a normal living-room soundbar has not been shown handing Bixby a live stream.
  • Partner feed: “400 partners” comes from the researcher’s reading of policy XML, not from a Samsung list released this month.
  • Company reply: Samsung has not addressed the October thread, the Flipper test, or the Northeastern opt-out table.

He said the full write-up, and a method for flashing the set, would follow. Until that file is public, the durable facts are the ones Samsung already printed, the ones Texas already extracted, and the ones a lab counted after the off switch.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of CUMBERNAULD MEDIA, which he runs as an independent publication after a decade in journalism spent moving from reporting to editing. His habit is to open the document before the summary of it. A company result is read from the filing rather than the press release, a court or regulatory decision from the judgment itself, a scientific finding from the paper and its methods section rather than the headline claim, and a sporting sanction from the governing body's own ruling. That approach shapes coverage across news, business and technology as much as science, sports and entertainment, and it carries into the lifestyle, travel, auto and gaming pages, where product specifications are checked against the manufacturer's sheet and, where possible, against Harry's own testing. Every number is checked before publication, and where a source's figures are disputed the story says so. Corrections follow a public policy and are marked on the page. Readers anywhere in the world who write in get a reply from him, and the address is support@cumbernauld-media.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending