Connect with us

BUSINESS

Household SIP Buyers Hold India on a Bear-Market Diwali

At Ignite 2026, SEBI and fund chiefs leaned on SIP households after foreign investors sold ₹3.07 lakh crore chasing an AI trade India never had.

Published

on

Household SIP buyers sent a record ₹32,490 crore into Indian mutual funds in September, even as foreign portfolio investors sold ₹3.07 lakh crore (about $32 billion) of Indian equities in 2026.

That bargain sat on the stage at NDTV Profit Ignite in Mumbai on 28 October, a Diwali session where the country’s market establishment asked those same households to keep buying after a year Raamdeo Agrawal, chairman and co-founder of Motilal Oswal Financial Services, called a “bear market Diwali.”

The Households Who Bought What Foreigners Sold

The Association of Mutual Funds in India logged monthly SIP contributions of ₹32,490 crore in September, up from ₹32,297 crore in August, with 10.06 crore contributing SIP accounts and SIP assets of ₹17.86 lakh crore. Equity funds took in ₹38,307 crore, the 67th straight month of inflows, and small-cap funds led with ₹9,039 crore even as industry assets fell to ₹82.64 lakh crore on mark-to-market losses.

Those rupees are no longer a sideshow. They are the bid. Foreign portfolio investors have been net sellers of Indian shares for most of 2026, and the people still showing up every month are salaried accounts on standing instructions.

Sandeep Tandon, founder and CIO of Quant Mutual Fund, had to spend part of his Ignite slot on the accusation that mutual funds now give foreign and private-equity sellers a clean exit. He said the last two years have been bad for India and that he hopes the worst is over, adding, “The market looks better now than it did two years ago.” The charge itself is the point. SIP money is large enough that the people who used to set the tape now leave through it.

Most Households Still Watch From Outside

SEBI Chairman Tuhin Kanta Pandey opened the regulator slot by celebrating scale, then immediately described how thin it still is. India has more than 15 crore unique securities-market investors, he said, with equity market capitalisation around 470 lakh crore, outstanding corporate bonds roughly 61 lakh crore, and mutual-fund assets about 83 lakh crore, a round figure against AMFI’s 30 September print of ₹82.64 lakh crore.

His own survey is less flattering. Kantar’s Investor Survey 2025, commissioned with AMFI and the market infrastructure institutions and covering more than 90,000 households across 400 cities and 1,000 villages, found that 63% of households are aware of at least one securities product, some 213 million homes, while only 9.5% invest.

THE SEBI CONVERSION GAP

Measure Finding
Households aware of a securities product 63% (213 million)
Households that invest 9.5% (32.1 million)
Urban participation 15%
Rural participation 6%
Investors with high or moderate market knowledge 36%
Households that prefer capital preservation nearly 80%

Delhi leads participation at 20.7% and Gujarat at 15.4%. Urban homes invest at more than double the rural rate, and only 36% of those already in the market show high or moderate knowledge. Pandey put the gap in one line: “Investing must be a choice made with open eyes.”

The same study says 22% of non-investors who already know the products intend to enter within a year, which is the pool the chairman wants. Unique investor counts and household counts are not the same thing, and the 15 crore figure sits beside a much smaller group of homes that actually put money in. The 32.1 million households actually invest, and nearly 80% of Indian homes still want their capital kept more than they want it grown. That is the customer the industry is asking to replace foreign cash.

Pandey listed the plumbing he thinks will help: cut foreign-portfolio onboarding from months to as little as five business days, put third-party monitors on IPO proceeds, weed out listed shell companies with no economic activity, work with Google on verified-app marks, and take a harder line on WhatsApp scams. Good regulation, he said, must deliver efficient access to capital, effective investor protection, and markets that are fair and resilient. The cash-market closing auction stays for a year, delinked from the derivatives settlement price on expiry day, and listing timelines for REITs and InvITs are being lined up with equity.

Why Foreign Money Went to Taiwan and Korea

Ashishkumar Chauhan, MD and CEO of the National Stock Exchange, did not blame a single bad week. He said foreign money has been leaving for three years because India does not have an AI story, and because most of the world’s fresh capital went to the United States, then Taiwan, then Korea.

India doesn’t have an AI story. Most money from across the world went into only the US, and then two other markets. One is Taiwan, the other is Korea.

Ashishkumar Chauhan, MD and CEO, NSE, at NDTV Profit Ignite

He sketched the size of that rotation in the same breath. Out of a 75-trillion-dollar market cap now, he said, the figure was probably 35 trillion or 40 trillion three years earlier, “and literally that surge is due to AI.” When markets move, he added, people take money from a market that does not have the story and put it where the story is, and cycles usually run ahead of themselves until smart money starts to leave.

Depository records match the complaint. CDSL’s calendar-year series shows net FPI equity outflows of ₹3.07 lakh crore in 2026 through 27 October, after a July and August pause that did not last.

FPI EQUITY FLOWS IN 2026

Period Net equity investment (₹ crore)
July 2026 +20,200
August 2026 +29,631
September 2026 -35,861
October 2026 (through 27 Oct) -46,748
Calendar 2026 total (through 27 Oct) -3,07,051

Chauhan’s way out is a rotation, not a new Indian AI champion. He called Indian IT firms the workhorses that will implement AI at lower cost than frontier labs, and said investors would start leaving extremely high-priced labs for those workhorses in one or two quarters. On IPOs he was blunter still: the issue price is not what matters, where the stock ends up is. He said he holds no shares himself and still checks the numbers every few minutes.

Ajit Dayal, founder of Quantum Advisors, added the terms foreigners actually underwrite. The rupee, he said, was fairly rock-steady until March 2025 and then started to slide. Global pension funds and sovereign wealth funds manage around $100 trillion, and the fight for that capital changes when interest rates rise. FIIs, he said, will keep scoring India on currency moves and tax before they return. Speaking on a long-term capital-gains cut, Agrawal reached for a wedding image: foreign investors are “baraatis,” and “we have to give them what they want.”

A Bear-Market Diwali on the Sensex

The tape on the day of the conference did not argue with Agrawal. The Sensex closed at 73,246.03, down 352.64 points or 0.48%, and the Nifty 50 closed at 22,698.85, down 50.90 points or 0.22%, with IT and oil-and-gas leading the drag as crude sat near $116 a barrel.

THE TAPE INTO SAMVAT 2083

  • Sensex close: 73,246.03 on 28 October, against around 84,400 at last year’s Diwali around 20 October 2025.
  • Nifty 50 close: 22,698.85, a second straight lower finish.
  • FPI year so far: ₹3.07 lakh crore of equity selling through 27 October.
  • SIP September: a record ₹32,490 crore, with SIP assets still 21.6% of industry AUM.

Agrawal’s advice sat on top of that math. “You need patience. People made huge returns between 2022-24 now excess returns are averaging out.” He also said market cap should not drive the buy list, and that large-cap and small-cap names can both work if the price is right. The 2022-24 boom is the hangover the SIP army is being asked to sit through.

S. Naren, executive director and CIO of ICICI Prudential AMC, said many large financials now look reasonably valued, and that FMCG and IT have already corrected a lot, even if he would not promise a sharp bounce. His rule was asset allocation: trim when a bubble forms, add in a crisis, and stop pretending geopolitics can be timed. “We often overestimate our ability to predict geopolitical events,” he said.

Mutual Funds Get Called the Exit Door

The 6:45 pm panel was titled “Mutual Fund Investors: Keeping the Faith,” which is a polite way of saying the faith is being tested. Radhika Gupta, MD and CEO of Edelweiss Mutual Fund, refused the panic register. “I’m a less dramatic person,” she said, adding that the worst case for an SIP investor is not bad at all, and that 10-year SIPs are never bad. She also said the wind has changed for asset managers and that the small-cap story needs a new script.

That calm is the product the industry is selling to the household that just watched foreigners leave. It is also why Tandon had to answer the exit-route point on camera.

WHAT THE FUND DESK TOLD SIP BUYERS

  • Radhika Gupta: The worst case for an SIP investor is not bad, and a 10-year SIP is never bad.
  • Sandeep Tandon: The last two years were bad for India, and the market looks better now than two years ago.
  • Dinshaw Irani: “Buy right sit tight” can work in mutual funds, not in single stocks, because “things are very dynamic.”
  • Vikas Khemani: Consumption is not slowing, new-age players are doing well, and “there is always froth in markets.”
  • S. Naren: Allocate by regime, cut bubbles, add in crises, and do not pretend to time geopolitics.

Irani, CEO and MD of Helios India, described his stock work as rejection rather than selection: “We don’t select stocks. We reject them.” Khemani, founder and CIO of Carnelian Asset Management, offered the line the hall will remember. “Watching the news is not bad. Watch NDTV. Watching your portfolio go up and down is bad.” Gupta’s less dramatic SIP pitch and Tandon’s better-than-two-years-ago call are the same product in different mouths: stay on the debit instruction while the foreign seller uses your bid.

Only 9% of Firms Keep Spending

Ranjay Gulati, the Paul R. Lawrence Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School, put a number on corporate nerve that rhymes with SEBI’s household number. In a downturn, he said, 91% of companies are pure cost cutters and only 9% invest in growth. “As organisations get bigger, they are designed to be risk averse.”

In a study, 91% of companies are pure cost cutters in down markets. Only 9% invest in growth.

Ranjay Gulati, Harvard Business School, at NDTV Profit Ignite

He said markets are at an inflection driven by artificial intelligence, and that he is studying AI-native firms that build operations around agents first and then hire people to work beside them. On adoption he split the field in three: some companies go all in, which he called reckless, some do nothing, which he called hesitation, and some move in a methodical way. The 9% who still spend in a down market are the corporate twin of the SIP account that does not stop. Most of the system, firm and household, is built to freeze.

Ben Powell, chief investment strategist for Middle East and APAC at the BlackRock Investment Institute, said he is “structurally positive on India in the long term,” then named the constraint that loops back to Pandey’s survey. The country’s test, he said, is whether it can mobilise its own savings to power its own growth. That is a polite description of the same 9.5%.

Damani’s Second-Best Time Is Now

Ramesh Damani, a BSE member, went the other way from Agrawal’s bear-market greeting. “The best time to invest was in 1991. The second-best time is now.” He said the next 20 to 30 years will be better for Indian financial markets than the last 20 to 30, and that if the AI trade unwinds, some of that capital could steer toward India. He also said the AI trade may not give investors a clean exit.

Near-term he was darker. He called the US president an “unchecked power,” said there is no good outcome for global markets in the US midterms, and warned that the man may refuse to concede if he loses. The next 15 days, he said, could be a stretch of higher risk for global markets. That clock started on the same afternoon the Sensex closed at 73,246.

The hall therefore held two clocks at once. Damani’s long clock says this is the second-best entry since 1991. Agrawal’s near clock says excess returns from 2022-24 are averaging out in a bear-market Diwali. Chauhan’s global clock says the AI bid is still elsewhere. Pandey’s survey clock says most Indian homes have not even started. The only clock that printed a record in September is the SIP one, and it belongs to the household that the rest of the system has decided will hold the bid until someone else wants the stock again.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of remarks made at NDTV Profit Ignite on 28 October 2026, together with published SEBI, AMFI and CDSL figures, and is for information only. It is not investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any security, mutual fund or SIP, or a forecast of market returns. Readers should consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser or other qualified financial professional who can consider their own goals, time horizon and risk before acting. Market levels, flow figures and speaker views reflect the sources as dated above and can change with the next session, the next AMFI print and the next depository update.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of CUMBERNAULD MEDIA, which he runs as an independent publication after a decade in journalism spent moving from reporting to editing. His habit is to open the document before the summary of it. A company result is read from the filing rather than the press release, a court or regulatory decision from the judgment itself, a scientific finding from the paper and its methods section rather than the headline claim, and a sporting sanction from the governing body's own ruling. That approach shapes coverage across news, business and technology as much as science, sports and entertainment, and it carries into the lifestyle, travel, auto and gaming pages, where product specifications are checked against the manufacturer's sheet and, where possible, against Harry's own testing. Every number is checked before publication, and where a source's figures are disputed the story says so. Corrections follow a public policy and are marked on the page. Readers anywhere in the world who write in get a reply from him, and the address is support@cumbernauld-media.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending