A recent Sunday Times league table has spotlighted a dramatic contrast in academic achievement between Aberdeen’s secondary schools, with Aberdeen Grammar School ranked among Scotland’s best (9th place) and Northfield Academy struggling near the bottom (18th in the bottom 20). This disparity has reignited discussions on the underlying causes of educational inequality in the city and how it can be addressed.
Aberdeen Grammar: A Beacon of Excellence
Aberdeen Grammar School has climbed to 9th place in the Sunday Times 2025 Scottish Secondary School League Table, a significant rise from its previous 15th position. It is now the only institution north of the central belt to break into the top ten, with 74% of its pupils achieving the Scottish government’s “gold standard” of five Highers, a 10% increase from the previous year.
This achievement has been widely attributed to the school’s unwavering focus on academic excellence and the dedication of both staff and students. The Sunday Times noted that “Aberdeen Grammar stands out as a beacon of educational success in the region,” highlighting its successful strategies and strong community support.
Northfield Academy: Signs of Recovery Amid Challenges
In stark contrast, Northfield Academy has faced significant challenges, with its performance placing it near the bottom of the national rankings. In 2021, only 7% of its pupils left with five or more Highers. Furthermore, the school received the lowest “unsatisfactory” grade in all four areas of a recent Education Scotland inspection, triggering a major overhaul of its approach.
Despite these setbacks, there are signs of recovery. Recent changes to the curriculum, including the introduction of vocational courses and bonding activities for new pupils, have led to a modest rise in attainment. For example, the number of S4 pupils achieving at least one SCQF Level 5 qualification increased by 8% compared to 2022. Additionally, a recent survey revealed that more students now feel safe at school, although challenges related to attendance and behavior persist.
Former pupil Finlay Mann reflected on his time at Northfield, noting that while the school has challenges, there are still opportunities for committed students. “For pupils who do actually pay attention and get on with it, there is a decent amount of opportunity. The teachers at Northfield acknowledge it is a challenging school, but most try their hardest, given the limited resources they have available,” Mann shared.
What’s Behind the Gap?
The Sunday Times league tables underscore a broader trend seen across Scotland: top-performing schools tend to be located in more affluent areas, while schools in deprived communities face greater challenges. Aberdeen Grammar, situated in a more prosperous part of the city, benefits from greater parental support, better resources, and a stable student body. In contrast, Northfield Academy serves a community with higher levels of deprivation, which affects both pupil achievement and the resources available to the school.
This stark contrast in performance, despite the schools being just a few miles apart, highlights the deep-rooted issue of educational inequality. The gap in attainment between these two schools is a reflection of broader societal inequalities, which persist in various educational systems across the country.
Possible Solutions to Address the Divide
To tackle the educational gap between schools like Aberdeen Grammar and Northfield Academy, experts and education bodies have suggested several potential solutions:
1. Targeted Support and Funding
-
Increasing investment in schools that serve disadvantaged areas, focusing on additional support needs, and providing adequate training for staff to better meet the diverse needs of their students.
2. Collaborative Improvement
-
Promoting a culture of collaboration among schools, encouraging the sharing of best practices, and supporting professional development for teachers across schools to improve educational outcomes.
3. Curriculum Flexibility
-
Expanding vocational and skills-based learning options, which have shown promising results in schools like Northfield Academy. Offering a wider range of qualifications can help engage students and better prepare them for the workforce.
4. Catchment Area Review
-
Reevaluating school catchment areas to consider socio-economic diversity, ensuring greater equity of access to high-performing schools for students in deprived areas.
5. Community Engagement
-
Involving parents, local organizations, and students in the planning of school improvements, ensuring that solutions are tailored to the unique needs of each community.
As local authorities and the Scottish Government consider their next steps, the overarching goal is clear: ensuring every child, no matter their postcode, has the opportunity to succeed in education and life.
