England will go head-to-head with Scotland in the highly anticipated Calcutta Cup match at Twickenham on Saturday. Head coach Steve Borthwick has kept faith in Marcus Smith despite recent criticism, while Ollie Chessum earns a promotion to the starting lineup. With England’s narrow 26-25 victory over France in the last round of the Six Nations reigniting hopes, the hosts will be eager to avenge recent defeats to their northern rivals.
Marcus Smith Retained Despite Criticism
The decision to stick with Smith as part of England’s playmaking axis has sparked debate. Some pundits have questioned his consistency, but Borthwick remains convinced that his talent will shine on the big stage.
- Smith has been England’s starting fly-half in recent matches, though his performances have drawn mixed reviews.
- His ability to orchestrate the attack remains crucial, especially with the likes of Owen Farrell absent from the squad.
- The coaching staff values his attacking flair and creativity, even amid calls for a more structured approach.
Borthwick’s selection suggests that he is prepared to back his players through thick and thin. Whether Smith repays that faith with a commanding display against Scotland remains to be seen.
Ollie Chessum Returns to the Starting Pack
The only change to England’s starting XV sees Chessum return to the fold, partnering Maro Itoje in the second row. The Leicester lock has endured a tough period with injuries but is now set for his first start since England’s previous loss to Scotland at Murrayfield a year ago.
One of England’s rising stars, the 24-year-old missed both the summer tour and the Autumn Nations Series. His absence was felt, but now he has a chance to make an impact.
“Ollie has worked incredibly hard to get back to full fitness,” said Borthwick. “His presence in the pack adds strength and mobility, which will be crucial against a strong Scottish side.”
Chessum’s inclusion is expected to bring added physicality and athleticism to England’s forward play. His ability to disrupt the opposition’s lineout and contribute in open play could prove invaluable in a match of this intensity.
England’s Recent Struggles Against Scotland
Despite being historically dominant in this fixture, England have struggled in recent years. Scotland have won four of the last seven encounters, including the last four in a row.
| Year | Result |
|---|---|
| 2023 | Scotland 29-23 England |
| 2022 | Scotland 20-17 England |
| 2021 | Scotland 11-6 England |
| 2020 | England 13-6 Scotland |
| 2019 | England 38-38 Scotland |
| 2018 | Scotland 25-13 England |
| 2017 | England 61-21 Scotland |
That record has added fuel to England’s determination to turn the tide. Twickenham hasn’t been the fortress it once was against the Scots, but Borthwick’s men will be desperate to restore pride on home soil.
Tactical Adjustments and Key Battles
England’s game plan is expected to revolve around physical dominance and set-piece efficiency. Scotland, on the other hand, will look to exploit space and play with tempo. A few key areas will likely decide the outcome:
- Breakdown Battle: England will need to neutralize Scotland’s ability to win turnovers, especially with Jack Dempsey and Rory Darge posing threats.
- Kicking Duel: Tactical kicking will be crucial, particularly with Finn Russell orchestrating Scotland’s attack.
- Scrum and Lineout: Chessum’s inclusion signals England’s intent to win the aerial contest and control the set-piece.
Scotland have proven adept at frustrating England in recent years, and Borthwick’s men must show composure under pressure to break the cycle.
