Newly released figures have revealed an alarming gap between reported cases of livestock worrying and actual convictions, sparking outrage among farmers and rural communities.
Shocking Conviction Rates Amid Rising Incidents
Despite nearly 60 charges being referred to the courts in the last year, only two people have been convicted for livestock worrying across Scotland. The data, disclosed by the Scottish Government, underscores a significant gap in the enforcement of laws meant to protect farmers and their animals.
Sheep farmer and MSP Tim Eagle voiced his frustration, stating, “Farmers are being robbed of their livelihoods while those responsible face little to no consequences.” His concerns echo the wider sentiment among those who rely on livestock farming, particularly as lambing season begins.
Prosecution Figures Paint a Grim Picture
According to the newly released statistics:
- 57 charges of livestock worrying were referred to the Crown Office in 2024-2025.
- Only six of these cases were prosecuted.
- Just two (4%) resulted in a conviction.
The figures indicate a troubling trend where reported incidents rarely translate into meaningful legal action, leaving farmers feeling unsupported.
Low Fines and Weak Deterrents
Adding to the frustration is the fact that the highest fine handed out since 2021 for livestock worrying has been less than £1,000. Many in the farming community argue that such penalties fail to act as a deterrent.
A local farmer, who wished to remain anonymous, remarked, “When irresponsible dog owners know the worst they might face is a small fine, they’re not going to take this seriously. We need stronger action.”
Calls for Stricter Legislation and Enforcement
With lambing season underway, the issue of livestock worrying is even more pressing. Farmers are urging lawmakers to strengthen enforcement and introduce tougher penalties to protect their animals and livelihoods.
Key demands include:
- Higher fines and potential custodial sentences for repeat offenders.
- Stronger legal backing for farmers to protect their livestock.
- Greater awareness campaigns to educate dog owners on responsible pet control.
Scotland’s rural communities are watching closely to see if the government will act on these concerns. Many argue that without meaningful legal consequences, the problem will only continue to worsen
