A breakthrough discovery or a false claim?
A team of physicists affiliated with several institutions in South Korea has posted two papers on the arXiv preprint server, claiming to have created a material that can conduct electricity without resistance at room temperature and normal pressure. The material, named LK-99, is said to be a product of a solid-state reaction between lanarkite and copper phosphide. The team has provided some evidence of superconductivity, such as zero resistance and the Meissner effect, but their claims have not been peer reviewed or replicated by other researchers.
What is superconductivity and why is it important?
Superconductivity is a phenomenon in which a material loses all electrical resistance when cooled below a certain critical temperature. This means that electric current can flow through the material without any loss of energy or generation of heat. Superconductors also exhibit other remarkable properties, such as expelling magnetic fields and levitating above magnets.
Superconductivity has many potential applications in various fields, such as power transmission, transportation, medical imaging, quantum computing, and more. However, most known superconductors require extremely low temperatures (close to absolute zero) and/or high pressures to operate, which limits their practical use and increases their cost.
How did the Korean team create LK-99?
According to the papers, the team used a sealed vacuum crystal tube with mixed powder of lanarkite (Pb2SO5) and copper phosphide (Cu3P). They then applied different heat treatment conditions to the tube and obtained a dark gray material that they named LK-99. The team claims that LK-99 is a new compound with the formula Pb10-xCux(PO4)O.
The team measured the electrical resistance and magnetic properties of LK-99 using various methods and instruments. They claim that LK-99 showed zero resistance at room temperature (around 25 degrees Celsius) and ambient pressure (around 1 atmosphere). They also claim that LK-99 exhibited the Meissner effect, which is a characteristic of superconductivity. In this effect, a superconductor expels an external magnetic field from its interior and creates an opposite magnetic field around it. The team has provided a video of LK-99 partially levitating above a magnet as a demonstration of this effect.
Why are the claims met with skepticism and criticism?
The claims made by the Korean team are extraordinary and unprecedented in the history of physics. If true, LK-99 would be the first material to achieve superconductivity at room temperature and normal pressure, which would be a revolutionary discovery that could transform the fields of electricity and electronics.
However, there are many reasons to doubt the validity and reliability of the claims. First of all, the papers have not been peer reviewed or published in any reputable scientific journal. This means that they have not been scrutinized by other experts in the field who can verify or challenge the methods, results, and conclusions of the papers.
Secondly, the papers lack many details and explanations that are essential for understanding and reproducing the experiment. For example, the papers do not provide any information on how LK-99 was characterized or identified as a new compound. They also do not explain how they controlled or eliminated possible sources of error or contamination in their measurements.
Thirdly, the papers contradict many established theories and observations about superconductivity. For instance, the papers suggest that LK-99 is a conventional superconductor that follows the BCS theory, which describes how electrons pair up to form Cooper pairs that can move without resistance through a lattice of atoms. However, this theory predicts that superconductivity should disappear at high temperatures and pressures due to thermal fluctuations and lattice vibrations that break up the Cooper pairs.
Moreover, the papers do not address or account for any previous experiments or studies that have failed to find or create room-temperature superconductors. There have been many attempts and claims of achieving this goal over the past decades, but none of them have been confirmed or accepted by the scientific community.
What are the next steps for verifying or falsifying the claims?
The only way to settle the controversy over LK-99 is to have independent and rigorous tests conducted by other researchers who can reproduce or refute the results reported by the Korean team. This would require sharing or sending samples of LK-99 to other laboratories around the world, as well as providing detailed protocols and procedures for preparing and measuring LK-99.
However, this may not be easy or feasible due to various factors, such as availability, accessibility, quality, safety, legality, ethics, and politics. For example, LK-99 contains lead (Pb), which is a toxic heavy metal that poses health and environmental risks. It may also be subject to export or import restrictions or regulations due to its potential military or industrial applications.
Therefore, it may take a long time and a lot of resources and efforts to verify or falsify the claims made by the Korean team. Until then, the scientific community and the public will have to wait and see whether LK-99 is a genuine breakthrough or a false claim.
Category: News Science
Meta Description: 🚨 A team of Korean physicists claims to have created a room-temperature superconductor, but their claims are met with skepticism and criticism. 🔎
URL Slug: korean-team-claims-room-temperature-superconductor
Image: room temperature superconductor levitating magnet